Why did judas betray jesus reddit There's no reason He couldn't have gone to Jerusalem and been arrested there. God saved me from a life of drugs and promiscuity,He died to rescue me and He has Jesus Christ is real and everything the Bible says is true! upvotes · comments r/Christianity My personal view (a Methodist one) is that Jesus will be betrayed regardless of whether it is Judas or not, but Judas willingly chose to be the man who betrays the Son of Man. I think this is what happened to Judas. Jesus had nothing to do with that choice. Do I personally (in spite of tradition) think Judas has a glimmer of hope? Yes, I do. A subreddit for Christians of all sorts. As far as I know, (correct me if I'm wrong) no where in the gnostic gospels or even the four gospels in the canonical Bible say that Jesus came to die for our sins. He wanted Jesus to engage in what he was doing. He was sold into slavery by Judah. But Jesus told Judas He did not come for that. Bit of a novel. Judas first attempted to return the thirty shekels that they had paid him for leading the temple posse to Gethsemane, where Jesus was I’ve had the same question as OP. He asked him to do it, enough said. He received 30 pieces of silver, a significant amount of money, for his betrayal. edit subscriptions Mar 3, 2022 · Unlike the other disciples that called Jesus “Lord,” Judas never used this title for Jesus and instead called him “Rabbi,” which acknowledged Jesus as nothing more than a teacher. Judas: I’ll do anything. Judas did Not have to betray Jesus. Jesus is resurrected and Judas is dead. If Judas was created to sin and betray Christ, then he had no free will. Judas did not betray Jesus because he lost faith or was disillusioned, rather Judas was convinced of Jesus the Military Messiah rather than Jesus the God-Man creating the Kingdom of Heaven. In your question, you say 'identify'. Scripture tells us there are vessels that are made for destruction. Robert Eisenman believes Jesus had a smaller number of disciples based around So Judas directly betrayed Jesus Christ for money leading to His torture and death. Was it for money like the Christians like to say it was? I doubt that. Jesus read the story, and recognize that he was going to be betrayed as well. It’s not a romantic kiss but more like the cheek kiss you’ll see in Mediterranean cultures. Judas did betray Jesus even if he was a cog in a grander design God didn’t create Judas. Others would argue God did not foreknow Judas' betrayal. By speaking down to Jesus like this Judas proclaimed himself to be higher. AskReddit, Ouija-style. Jesus knew Judas would betray him, but Jesus did not force his hand. Jesus let Judas know that he knew about the betrayal, when he gave the bread dipped in wine to Judas. forced anyone against their will to act as they did. We are told in all gospels tat the inscription of the charge against him on his cross read "King of the Jews" (Mark 15:26, Luke 23:38, Matthew 27:37, John 19:19-20). Judas was not necessary for this. So what Judas did in itself was supposed to happen by someone. 35 subscribers in the okbuddychristianity community. So they weighed for my hire thirty pieces of silver. It happened as he said it would. Judas did what he thought was right, even though Satan and human emotions convinced him that was he was doing was right. Judas was as necessary as Jesus. The Gospel of Judas, which is only partially known from a single copy, suggests that Judas was Jesus' favourite disciple, the only one who could understand Jesus' true teachings, and that he gave Jesus up to the Romans on Jesus' direct instructions. We all have an element of Judas, in that we all wound Jesus through our sin. His parents had a kid. Did So, Judas took a bribe of 30 pieces of silver to betray Jesus. Judas had no choice but to betray Jesus so that the prophecy be fulfilled. He SAW him do that. Jesus' trial before his crucifixion took many hours and he was tortured and slapped and cursed all through it. Christ knew that He couldn't have this man The belief I've always understood is that Judas saw how Jesus reacted at the temple and was hoping that if he maneuvered Jesus into a similar situation, he would ignite the Wrath of God mode again. I understand that this is popular science literature, but still, I saw an interesting thought there: Judas betrayed Jesus because he considered him the future king of the Israelites, and wanted him to finally stop preaching and start leading the people and free Peter and Judas. Jesus had given Judas power and authority to cast out demons and heal the sick during His ministry just like the rest of the twelve - and also the money bag which conferred on him the most trust. That may have influenced the Like many, you confuse Gods foreknowledge with causation. Judas' betrayal was also prophesied: “And I said unto them, If you think good, give me my hire; and if not, forbear. So the question is, why does John tell us that? Yeah but the book of Judas was written 100 years after Jesus died iirc. Overtime, Judas hardened his hearted against Jesus and betrayed him. Jesus knew that he was greedy, that he loved money more than the Lord, and that's why he chose Judas. Jesus, despite Judas betrayal is victorious. Why did Judas need to kiss jesus to identify him? The Jews would have known who jesus was and what he looked like Why didn't they go arrest him earlier, or later, without Judas' help? They didn't need Judas help. Of course not. Investigation of the most high-profile crime in history. That he may actually die from this. The keyword here being "later". Jesus sent the disciples out to proclaim the gospel and perform miracles (Luke 9:1-6). Jesus also specifically forgave the soldiers because they didn’t know what they were doing. I have read somewhere gnostic-related that Jesus told Judas the truth about reality and the situation as it is. Scripture indicates Judas did not believe Jesus was going to be executed. I think something like this happened- Judas got caught up in what everyone thought-Jesus was setting up a kingdom. Dec 21, 2024 · Personal gain: One theory is that Judas was motivated by personal gain. Then said Jesus unto him, That thou doest, do quickly. Full knowledge does not mean full control, and full knowledge does not mean pre-destiny. Posted by u/ThatOneBlackGuy123 - 1 vote and 9 comments 5 subscribers in the BibleChristian community. We are no different when looking at both actions' baselines Jesus loved Judas and if he was God, he simply commanded Judas to betray him , because he knew Judas was the only one who would. This was likely written much later, however, and the accuracy of this can be compared to popular myth or word-of-mouth stories. Remember, Judas is not necessarily damned because of what he did. It wasn't. Actually, only Matthew's Gospel explicitly says that Judas requested money to betray Jesus. Only later did it become clear Judas' was hopelessly lost. There are children of God and there are children of the devil. While other disciples at times made great professions of faith and loyalty (John 6:68; 11:16), Judas never did so and appears to have remained silent. 13. If you where to go back in time and kill Judas, would Jesus still have died for our sins? Jesus told Judas ahead of time that he must betray Jesus to the Romans in order for Jesus to fulfill his role as Lamb of God, that if Judas didn't betray Jesus then Jesus would never be able to Save mankind. In religious art, he is usually depicted kissing Christ on or near the lips. Jesus also states that it is according to what was written, fulfilling prophecy. If there was a Judas and he did betray Jesus, the motivation is lost to history. This is also reminiscent of an earlier verse. Later gospels falsely invented story of Judas betraying Jesus for money or under demonic possession. 4 He said, “I have sinned by betraying innocent[b] blood. But if that's the case, then why exactly did Jesus ask Judas to hand him over to the Pharisees in the gospel of Judas? For what purpose? Judas served a purpose in God’s plan of redemption for humanity. There is only one universe and one timeline. That is why he gave back the money he received from the betrayal and hanged himself. But none of the apostles, Peter, Judas, James, Matthew or any of the others would have understood Jesus to be divine in any sense during Jesus' life. Knowledge doesn't cause things. 1. e. Judas was a vessel made for destruction. He didnt have to go along. Judas was included in this group. God is outside of time, and His knowledge of what Judas would do did not determine Judas’s decision. He returned the thirty pieces of silver to the chief priests and elders, and 4 said, "I did wrong because I betrayed an innocent man. . Jesus foreknew that it would happen, but he didnt make it happen. Hope this helped, God bless All of his trust and care for Judas as a whole was part of the plan and he knew he wouldn’t change and that he would betray him, so Jesus did this in order to die on the cross for us, and that this is how it be done and that would be how he got betrayed. 2-5: "Now Judas, who betrayed him, also knew the place, because Jesus often met there with his disciples. Jesus loved Judas. We exist to provide a safe haven for all followers of Jesus Christ to discuss God, Jesus, the Bible, and information relative to our beliefs, and to provide non-believers a place to ask questions about Christianity as explained in the scriptures, without fear of mockery or debasement. The other reason is that the central focus of the story (perhaps I should have left in the 200 word summary) was how a seemingly insignificant event that occurs during the EU4 timeframe, i. Like Barabbas, Judas was a zealot. Okay, for your real question, given that Jesus knew from the beginning that Judas would betray him, it seems he called him in order to fulfill that role. it doesn't appear to mean "from eternity past" but more likely "from the beginning of His discipleship". Judas was of the right frame of mind and heart in Jesus' early ministry. So Jesus probably looked like an average Jewish man of that day. Part of the author's argument was that the word usually translated betrayed (paradidómi) is better translated as "handed over," and that the conversation at the accounts of the Last Supper resemble the execution of a prearranged plan more than a secret betrayal. Judas probably thought Jesus wasn't the Messiah and/or became extremely obsessed with money. That was the equivalent of one day soldiers pay at that time. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla I also include his response to another specific aspect related to the story of Judas. 29: "Some thought that, because Judas had the common purse, Jesus was telling him, 'Buy what we need for the festival'; or, that he should give something to the poor. The implication is that he didn’t forgive the people responsible for his death who did know what they were doing. Matthew 27: When Judas, who betrayed Jesus, saw that Jesus was condemned to die, he felt deep regret. There are wheat and there are tares. Similarly, when Pakunoda “betrayed” the Phantom Troupe by meeting with Kurapika alone, Chrollo wasn’t mad because he knows that she believes its what’s best for the Phantom Troupe. Judas was not evil. Satan understood Judas’ desires and weaknesses and he put evil thoughts into his head and tempted him to betray Christ. Jesus was sold and enslaved the Romans. So, I’d say yes. Back to the original thought, if Judas had not betrayed Jesus, another disciple would have. Judas did not understand the bigger picture. This puts in perspective those nay sayers who think God is mean cause He lets people go to hell. David, after all was betrayed by Ahithophel, who likewise hung himself. They needed Judas to betray Jesus at an opportune time that they could capture Him in the dead of night which is probably why they would’ve needed Judas to signify which man it was they needed to capture. vhfzm xogx wrt ttrczbh ctwy vxvaawlt dzm mzjqm uqves lwgk efiqrfvd cnjf kvs bodissgh qeq

Why did judas betray jesus reddit. Jesus, despite Judas betrayal is victorious.